ES / EN
- July 15, 2025 -
No Result
View All Result
OnCubaNews
  • World
  • Cuba
  • Cuba-USA
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Infographic
  • Culture
    • Billboard
  • Sports
  • Styles / Trends
  • Media
  • Special
  • Cuban Flavors
  • World
  • Cuba
  • Cuba-USA
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Infographic
  • Culture
    • Billboard
  • Sports
  • Styles / Trends
  • Media
  • Special
  • Cuban Flavors
OnCubaNews
ES / EN
Home Cuba Science Science in Cuba

Are there pseudosciences in Cuba?

by
  • Malvy Souto
    Malvy Souto,
  • malvy
    malvy
October 9, 2014
in Science in Cuba
0
In 2009 the Ministry of Public Health (MINSAP) issued Resolution No. 261 which included some practices as legitimate within their specialty number 52, known as "Natural and Traditional Medicine"

In 2009 the Ministry of Public Health (MINSAP) issued Resolution No. 261 which included some practices as legitimate within their specialty number 52, known as "Natural and Traditional Medicine"

For many Steve Jobs is just a name or a good American film. For some, he was a genius of the technology company, creator of devices like Ipad and Iphone. For a few, a patient with a rare pancreatic tumor that luckily in his case could be removed. For almost anyone, he was a man of science who lost his life paradoxically by preferring naturopathic treatments without scientific basis. Steve Jobs was a victim of the so-called pseudo-science, and that is not highlighted in the news.

Perhaps this is the most publicized case, but every year in the world lives are lost to the seductive set of theories, covered in a mystical tradition or technological advanced, which are offered as an alternative to traditional medical practice. Such is the case of Canadian boy Tyrell Deck, who died of a treatable bone cancer by the reluctance of parents to chemotherapy in pursuit of “natural products” or the young Italian who was killed by a simple bronchopneumonia treated with homeopathic remedies.

Pseudoscience are the knowledge, beliefs or practices that are not governed by experimentation, and instead present concepts supposedly scientific, says the Doctor in Physical Sciences Arnaldo González Arias in his article The science upside down.

This reality may seem remote from the Cuban health system, supported by decades of evidence and a dedication to universal access to higher medical care. However, for the last few days it is traveling on the blogosphere and the site of the magazine Youth Technical a statement of the Scientific Council of the Marta Abreu University in central Las Villas province on the so-called pseudoscience; undoubtedly the tip of the iceberg of a controversy that takes place in the scientific community of the island.

Medicine without surnames (Osvalo de Melo).
Medicine without surnames (Osvalo de Melo).

In fact, in less visible areas-keeping with the metaphor of the iceberg, a debate published by the website of the journal Technical Youth about the importance of evidence and experimentation in some practices of Natural and Traditional Medicine in Cuba, has started.

The exchange is located entirely in the Cuban Journal of Public Health and later became the book Medicine without surnames by UH publishing house. Also in 2012 we learned of a Declaration of the Cuban Society of Mathematics and Computer Science, Physics and Chemistry of the need to promote the scientific method, which the Cuban Society of Oncology, Radiotherapy and Nuclear Medicine joined.

Related Posts

Dagmar García. Photo taken from: @FinlayInstituto

The Lancet highlights work of Dagmar García, one of Soberana 02 vaccine’s architects

September 16, 2024
The Cuban lung ventilator Combiovent. Photo: Abel Rojas Barallobre/Juventud Rebelde.

Cuban lung ventilator “in introduction phase” in hospitals on island

September 15, 2024
Cuban laboratory. Photo: Scientific American

Cuba stands out in World Scientists Rankings 2024

January 13, 2024
Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (CIGB), in Havana, Cuba. Photo: Otmaro Rodríguez/OnCuba Archive.

Safety of technological platform of Cuban dengue vaccine candidate validated

March 24, 2023

The question is: are there pseudosciences in Cuba?

In 2009 the Ministry of Public Health (MINSAP) issued Resolution No. 261 which included some practices as legitimate within their specialty number 52, known as “Natural and Traditional Medicine”. These included herbal or plant science, apitherapy, traditional Asian medicine, ozone therapy, medical hydrology, traditional therapeutic exercises, nutritional counseling naturalist, homeopathy and flower essence therapy as alternatives for prevention, treatment, cure and rehabilitation of diseases.

However, the Scientific Council of the Central University says in his first point that “the university management is aware that there is a relatively large set of practices that have not been obtained by scientific methods (…) identified by the name pseudoscience (false science). Concrete examples: homeopathy, energy pyramid, floral therapy, dowsing (using pendulums), biorhythms, ufology (regarding UFOs), cryptozoology … “ It is striking that in this group it includes two treatments authorized by the Ministry of Public Health in 2009.

In this line coincides Specialist in Internal Medicine, Professor, Consultant and Master of Science in Medical Education, José A. Fernández Sacasas, who says that “to preserve the credit and prestige attained, natural and traditional medicine in Cuba should take distances from practices like homeopathy and flower essence therapy. ”

Homeopathy is based on the extreme dilution of a substance into a harmless liquid-water or alcohol and water. The rationale is precisely that “like cures like ‘, this dilution enhances the effect explains Doctor in Physics and coordinator of the book Medicine without surnames, Osvalo de Melo. “You know from the beginning of the twentieth century that the substance is composed of atoms and atoms in any substance are many, but not infinite, as evidenced by the number of Avogadro *. If you start to dilute several times an active ingredient in water you end up running out of any atom in the starting material. So we see that the bases are unusual, are completely out of science and common sense, “he says.

According to Dr. Arnaldo González, numerous national articles that support the therapy fail to mention the placebo effect.
According to Dr. Arnaldo González, numerous national articles that support the therapy fail to mention the placebo effect.

Meanwhile, Second Degree Specialist and Master of Natural and Traditional Medicine, Dr. Magaly Carrero, argues that progress has been made in the study of the mechanisms of action of homeopathy and it is proposed that is at a molecular physical level. “We, homeopathic physicians have biochemical and biophysical specialists working on research medical sciences that help us to understand these mechanisms in the human body, since we are convinced of the results.”

But “if homeopathy worked no controlled trials would exist, nor comprehensive systematic reviews, editorials in prestigious journals such as The Lancet and statements like the one by Spanish Ministry of Health to reaffirm their ineffectiveness” refutes the Doctor of Health Sciences, Luis Carlos Silva from the National Health Information Center.

Already since 2009, the World Health Organization stated that homeopathy was not effective for the prevention or cure for AIDS, tuberculosis, flu, malaria or diarrhea, according to an article in the newspaper El Pais, on August 29of that same year.

In the case of flower essence therapy, this has its origins in the early twentieth century and is due to physician Edward Bach. During a visit to the London countryside, the doctor discovered alleged similarities between flowers and some personological human traits. He described 38 original remedies, to which he added one of “rescue”, a five-preparation mixture for deep crisis. These solutions with floral base “are simple, effective and free of side effects,” says the First Degree Specialist in general medicine, Felipe Abreu; while clarifying that “XXI century science has not yet explained how it works.”

The Doctor in Physics Arnaldo González Arias said in a literature review found that multiple clinical trials dismiss the validity of floral therapy and that in the national articles that support it, are diagnosed methodological flaws since they don’t mention the placebo effect (a psychological effect of improvement that the patient may experience) or blind experiment.

These positions are part of a critical movement that supports the idea that medical science is not a matter of opinion, but of demonstrations, with the experimental method as a center for the confirmation or refutation of the hypothesis. This does not mean you should not keep trying in the way of validation of both practices. Much less it involves, in any of its approaches, a denial of the potential of natural and traditional medicine (MNT) in Cuba.

According to Dr. Arnaldo González, numerous national articles that support the therapy fail to mention the placebo effect.
According to Dr. Arnaldo González, numerous national articles that support the therapy fail to mention the placebo effect.

One of the greatest achievements of the Revolution was the establishment of a system of free and universal health care, under the philosophy of the union of practice, teaching and research. In this context the introduction of natural and traditional medicine becomes a policy guideline that is reflected in guideline number 158 of the Economic and Social Policy of the Communist Party of Cuba, governing document of existing transformations in the country.

“It was very successful to call to health professionals to introduce MNT. I think of the possibility of mastering the scientific basis for the application of medicinal plants and their assets for the relief of ailments (phytotherapy) and even early study natural products in countries where we provide medical collaboration to assess its possible use in the island, “emphasizes Doctor of Technical Sciences and Member of the Academy of Sciences of Cuba, Juan V. Lorenzo Ginori.

Dr. Jorge A. Biological Sciences Bergado, professor and researcher at the Center for Neurological Restoration, summarizes the collective position by stating that “the criticisms are not aimed at all the elements that today are grouped under the name of Natural and Traditional Medicine, research of natural products is welcome when it is done well, the same could be said of acupuncture.”

“It is not to be against the strange things, but against things that have not been thoroughly tested by the scientific method,” says Melo.

Maximum attention to the development of natural and traditional medicine is a premise of the Cuban strategy in health policy; In the opinion of several experts we must ensure that under its umbrella some practices lacking sufficient experimental and theoretical support take shelter.

As the teacher Sacasas Fernández put it: “Natural Medicine, yes; supernatural medicine, no”.

  • Malvy Souto
    Malvy Souto,
  • malvy
    malvy
Previous Post

Cuba revitalizes cooperation with Norway in oil industry

Next Post

Industriales fan till the end

Malvy Souto

Malvy Souto

Periodista. Escribe de temas económicos y de actualidad. Le encantaría “encontrarle la vuelta al mundo”, aunque el mundo se empeñe en darle la vuelta a ella...

malvy

malvy

Next Post
Industriales en los Estados Unidos

Industriales fan till the end

The festival pays permanent tribute to Santiago Alvarez, one of the most important masters of the documentary genre in Cuba.

Santiago Alvarez, documentaries "now" and forever

Letters from Cuba under attack

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

The conversation here is moderated according to OnCuba News discussion guidelines. Please read the Comment Policy before joining the discussion.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Read

  • OFAC.S. Department of the Treasury. Photo: Marita Pérez Díaz.

    OFAC fines U.S. company over $600,000 for shipping to Cuba

    37 shares
    Share 15 Tweet 9
  • Staying silent in Cuba: a choice?

    13 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • MSMEs barely growing and their slowdown hinders competition and economic dynamism

    12 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • Los Palacios, land of Cuban rice harvested by Vietnamese

    19 shares
    Share 8 Tweet 5
  • Trump reinstates hard-line Cuba embargo as Havana condemns US measure as “criminal”

    37 shares
    Share 15 Tweet 9

Most Commented

  • Photo: Kaloian.

    Private sector and tourism in Cuba. Why not?

    12 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • About us
  • Work with OnCuba
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Moderation policy for comments
  • Contact us
  • Advertisement offers

OnCuba and the OnCuba logo are registered® trademarks of Fuego Enterprises, Inc., its subsidiaries or divisions.
OnCuba © by Fuego Enterprises, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • World
  • Cuba
  • Cuba-USA
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Infographic
  • Culture
    • Billboard
  • Sports
  • Styles / Trends
  • Media
  • Special
  • Cuban Flavors

OnCuba and the OnCuba logo are registered® trademarks of Fuego Enterprises, Inc., its subsidiaries or divisions.
OnCuba © by Fuego Enterprises, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}