ES / EN
- May 12, 2025 -
No Result
View All Result
OnCubaNews
  • World
  • Cuba
  • Cuba-USA
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Infographic
  • Culture
    • Billboard
  • Sports
  • Styles / Trends
  • Media
  • Special
  • Cuban Flavors
  • World
  • Cuba
  • Cuba-USA
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Infographic
  • Culture
    • Billboard
  • Sports
  • Styles / Trends
  • Media
  • Special
  • Cuban Flavors
OnCubaNews
ES / EN
Home Opinion Columns Counterbalance

Marches and countermarches: the economic policy’s back-and-forths

If we all agree, why is it that what should happen doesn’t occur?

by
  • Dr.C Juan Triana Cordoví
April 4, 2019
in Counterbalance
0
Photo: Osbel Concepción.

Photo: Osbel Concepción.

I have written this column driven by the discussions around the papers presented at the Annual Seminar of the Center for Cuban Economy Studies of the University of Havana, which that center has held year after year for more than 20 years and this time with the additional motivation of celebrating its 30 years of being founded. It also coincides with the first 30 years of the beginning of the crisis we call the Special Period. Cuba survived that crisis, heightened by that “small obstacle” that is the U.S. blockade. But surviving the crisis is not developing.

They have been 30 tremendous years, of transcendental events, of almost constant marches and countermarches.

At the beginning of that Period… changes were introduced that promoted greater decentralization in the state business sector in search of greater efficiency. Foreign investment was identified as a positive ―though unwanted― element for our battered economy; self-employment was given greater openness ―it is true that reluctantly; and the dollar was introduced into the national circulation of currencies, to de facto create the exchange and monetary duality in which a generation of Cubans has already been born and lived.

Then we witnessed a first countermarch that led to restrictions to self-employment; the slowdown of foreign investment projects, with new demands and requirements for them; the non-renegotiation for the continuity of some and the closing of others together with a strong offensive to reduce the commercial branches of foreign companies in Cuba. In addition, the exit of the dollar from current operations was decreed to be replaced by the CUC and a single account was created that, among other effects, motivated the economy to start undergoing a process of real devaluation of the CUC. This has brought us to the famous CL and the complex financial situation that the country must solve today.

As of 2007, President Raúl Castro took a group of measures that meant an opening that had never been experienced before. In his own words, he recognized the strategic nature of the need to undertake a reform of the state business system, made explicit the support of the political leadership for self-employment, introduced and defended non-agricultural cooperatives and raised the strategic need to attract and use foreign direct investment; a new law and a policy associated with it and the Special Mariel Development Zone were approved. The migration law also changed and for the first time in almost 60 years Cubans could opt for a visa for any country without having to be commended by anyone.

But again the countermarches appeared. The creation of the Higher Organization of Corporate Management that, far from achieving more autonomy for the state enterprise, generated greater centralization and bureaucracy, distancing the decisions away from where they should be made, and converting them into dwarf emulators of their own ministries: a parasitic system of the state business system. The policy towards self-employment was also “revised” with more restrictions. And we are still expecting greater facilities for foreign investment that allow the country to reduce the time it takes to approve new businesses and achieve speedier bureaucratic processes that facilitate their establishment. Meanwhile, the approval of new cooperatives seems like a process submerged in some lost glacier in the Himalayas. It is also true that in recent months we have fortunately seen a certain rectification of the August 2018 decrees on self-employment. It must also be said that the recently announced new measures regarding it represent greater openness.

Related Posts

Photo: Erickxander Spengler.

Of incentives and marabú charcoal

April 18, 2025
Photo: Otmaro Rodríguez

Of distortions and development

March 24, 2025
Photo: Kaloian

Can Cuban export revenues increase?

February 22, 2025
Photo: Kaloian

Knowing the government program

February 7, 2025

………

Caption:

GDP growth rates (1997 prices)

Annual rates

Average 12-18

………..

But the list and the money still don’t tally. Although both Raúl Castro Ruz and Miguel Díaz-Canel Bermúdez have emphasized the need to overcome resistance, to change stagnant minds, to achieve coherence between promulgated policies, reality and the programmatic documents approved by all the Cuban people, including the new Constitution of the Republic that will be proclaimed in just a few days.

If we all agree, why is it that what should occur doesn’t happen? My friend Goyo wonders.

To reduce those reasons to whims, to ill will, to incompetence, to laziness and indolence of some, would be to adopt a too simplifying position, although we can also find a little of all that. However, I prefer to use other tools to try to understand, at least in part, this great contradiction and the complexity of the processes that Cuba faces.

Maybe we can find some answers in the institutional economy.

……….

Caption:

Politicas = Economic, social policies, etc.

Sistema = Political system

Cultura = Culture, ideology and informal regulations

Estado = State

Empresas = Enterprises

Familias = Families

Sistema judicial = Judicial system

Capacidad = Bureaucratic-administrative capacity

Naturaleza = Nature and balance of social interests

…………

Assuming a certain international environment, the graph illustrates the basic idea of ​​the institutional economy from which the behavior of the main economic agents of any country (that is, families, the State and enterprises) as well as the policies put into practice, are determined by the quality of the rules of the game (the institutions) and that these in turn are generated and conditioned by and from the political system, culture, ideology, bureaucratic and administrative capacity and the judicial system. They are the ones who generate and at the same time must comply with the policies of all kinds that define the incentives under which these three agents operate.

They work within an environment shaped by the conditions of the international economy and politics and by national policies and conditions. On the first little can be done except exercise a good capacity for adaptation and negotiation. On the second you can do almost everything.

National policies must allow strategies to be realized at the lowest possible cost, facilitating and encouraging those transactions between the three agents.

The coherence of the policies, of the programs, of the plans, will depend greatly on whether these systems are aligned and produce COHERENT rules of the game with the objectives of each country; that is, incentives adapted to those realities and purposes.

It occurs, however, that each of these five systems has a relative degree of independence, delay and low capacity for reacting. Hence the great difficulty of achieving the desired coherence.

The learned culture, the professed ideology, the political preferences, the created interests, the capacity to facilitate or obstruct laws and decrees that have been issued, have some degree of influence on those rules of the game.

It happens in all countries, but the fact that it happens in everyone with a certain degree of greater or lesser impact can’t serve as comfort, but rather only as a reference.

I illustrate it with our day-to-day facts:

  • We aspire to have more efficient state enterprises, but the conception of the plan doesn’t leave enough room for these enterprises to seek that efficiency.
  • We hear that the results of the state enterprises have improved but the effects of this improvement don’t translate into economic growth.
  • We aspire to state enterprises investing more but the “contribution” they are forced to deliver conspires against that purpose and is part of the reasons for their under capitalization.
  • We want to improve and grow in exports, but we have enough “negative incentives” (exchange rate, wages, excess restrictions) that hinder that purpose.
  • We need innovative state-owned enterprises, but the way in which the “plan” and the regulations for the creation of wages and the distribution of profits are conceived are contradictory to that purpose, in the same way that the culture of risk and competition is not promoted.
  • We declare that the “non-state sector” is more than a traveling companion for a prosperous and sustainable socialism, but we keep a positive list of jobs and a law on cooperatives still hasn’t been issued nor a law on small and medium enterprises.
  • We want to keep our highly qualified workforce but the wages paid encourage emigration to other sectors or other countries and professionals are not allowed to exercise “self-employment” in their own professions.
  • We need to raise the investment rate, but we don’t encourage the mobilization of “non-state” national resources for this.
  • We think first in controlling before promoting.
  • We are better trained in identifying threats than in taking advantage of opportunities.

The reasons why these contradictions accompany us and have accompanied us have to do, to a great extent, with what I tried to illustrate above. With the existence of political and ideological cultures that resist “updating,” even with personal behaviors marked by what they previously learned, with prejudices, with legislations that are often obsolete, but still valid, with gray spaces that allow “personal interpretations” and that condition, make difficult, delay the best purposes a country may have and make it extraordinarily difficult to achieve the desired coherence and with created personal interests difficult to renounce.

The “transaction costs” are huge. They are difficult to measure. Many times they are intangible, but without doubt they participate in an important way in many of the problems that Cuba faces today, among which are:

  • low economic growth rates,
  • negative trade balance,
  • high commercial dependence and
  • high concentration of foreign trade in markets and products,
  • high financial costs,
  • wasting the high qualification of our workforce,
  • high rate of emigration of young people with intermediate and higher education,
  • high technological dependence,
  • low flows of foreign capital, etc., etc.

This is a serious question. We shouldn’t think that nothing can be done, just the opposite. It is necessary to understand that the future is won day by day, in a difficult struggle with a multi-complex reality and that every day we have to work for that necessary coherence to which we all sometimes contribute not precisely in the best way.

Those are not win-win processes. On the contrary, almost all are win-lose processes. None of them is free of costs, but with good institutional designs ―with coherent rules of the game― those costs can be made as low as possible.

We have everything we need to change that reality; a vision of the country, a long-term development plan under construction, a concerted Constitution closer to our realities today that will be proclaimed shortly and, above all, most importantly, a people like there are few.

  • Dr.C Juan Triana Cordoví
Tags: cuban economy in 2019new economic measures in Cubaspecial period in Cuba
Previous Post

Pablo and Varela in new days of glory

Next Post

Cuba starts giving out free preventive HIV pill

Dr.C Juan Triana Cordoví

Dr.C Juan Triana Cordoví

Next Post
Pre-exposure prophylaxis pill (PrEP) for the preventive treatment of HIV. Photo: t13.cl

Cuba starts giving out free preventive HIV pill

Cuban migrants last March 23, 2019, in a shelter on the border of Ciudad Juárez, in the state of Chihuahua (Mexico). Photo: Alejandro Bringas/EFE.

Thousands of Cubans stranded in Ciudad Juárez, on the Mexican-U.S. border

Leydi García Lugo, medical student victim of feminicide in Villa Clara. Photo: Victim’s Facebook profile.

Medical student murdered in Villa Clara

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

The conversation here is moderated according to OnCuba News discussion guidelines. Please read the Comment Policy before joining the discussion.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Read

  • The Enchanted Shrimp of the Cuban Dance

    2950 shares
    Share 1180 Tweet 738
  • Cuban Cardinal before the conclave: “There is a desire to maintain the legacy of Pope Francis”

    35 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • Cuban economy, the “regulations” and the shoe

    14 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • Deported and without her baby daughter: Heidy Sánchez’s desperation

    10 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • Non-alpha IL-2 Mutein: a Cuban hope for cancer

    6 shares
    Share 2 Tweet 2

Most Commented

  • Photovoltaic solar park in Cuba. Photo: Taken from the Facebook profile of the Electricity Conglomerate (UNE).

    Solar parks vs. blackouts: between illusions and reality (I)

    15 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • Fernando Pérez, a traveler

    11 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • Solar parks vs. blackouts: between illusions and reality (II and end)

    13 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • The “Pan de La Habana” has arrived

    31 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8
  • China positions itself as Cuba’s main medical supplier after signing new contracts

    27 shares
    Share 11 Tweet 7
  • About us
  • Work with OnCuba
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Moderation policy for comments
  • Contact us
  • Advertisement offers

OnCuba and the OnCuba logo are registered® trademarks of Fuego Enterprises, Inc., its subsidiaries or divisions.
OnCuba © by Fuego Enterprises, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • World
  • Cuba
  • Cuba-USA
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Infographic
  • Culture
    • Billboard
  • Sports
  • Styles / Trends
  • Media
  • Special
  • Cuban Flavors

OnCuba and the OnCuba logo are registered® trademarks of Fuego Enterprises, Inc., its subsidiaries or divisions.
OnCuba © by Fuego Enterprises, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}